Beyond Blight: The Man-Made Origins of the Great Famine

The suffering of An Gorta Mór, or the Great Famine, marked a demographic tragedy for Ireland. Over one million people died, and another million emigrated, leading to a nearly 25% population decline in just seven years. The crisis began with a fungal disease that devastated Ireland's principal food and economic resource—the potato—resulting in widespread starvation and disease in the years that followed. While the blight's arrival in 1845 was a natural disaster, the British government's neglect amplified its catastrophic effects.

Britain’s response to the tragedy failed to adequately address Ireland’s suffering. Instead of reliable support, the British government offered ideological rigidity, inaction, and poor execution. Consequently, the origins of the Great Famine were not merely natural but also man-made, deeply rooted in the British government’s disregard for the depth of the crisis.

The origins of the famine are linked to Ireland’s strained relationship with the British government. Ireland had been under English control since the 12th century but was formally incorporated into the United Kingdom with the 1801 Act of Union. However, the Anglo-Irish relationship remained far from equal. The systematic marginalisation of the Irish population, particularly the Catholic majority, stemmed from oppressive colonial policies. For example, the Penal Laws severely restricted Catholic rights and denied them access to education and political participation. This legacy of discrimination laid the groundwork for the hardships and neglect that culminated in the famine.

Foremost, Ireland needed to source food after losing its staple crop, but the British failed to provide a long-term solution. Compounding this failure, repeated attempts to support the hungry were poorly executed and ultimately ineffective. Initially, the British government, under Robert Peel, sought to address the crisis with the £10,000 purchase of Indian corn, or maize, from America, which was intended to be sold cheaply to the Irish to stabilise food prices. Seemingly, this measure appeared to be a viable solution to supplement the Irish diet, yet the plan overlooked a fundamental problem: how could a destitute population afford this lower-cost grain? Wages were already too low to keep up with the rising prices of other essential ingredients like wheat and flour, forcing many to rely solely on maize.

This reliance on maize, however, brought its own problems. The Irish population, unaccustomed to maize as a source of subsistence, began to suffer from a range of dietary-related illnesses. The lack of proper nutrition and the sudden dietary shift further compounded the suffering, revealing the inadequacy of Peel's relief measures. What was intended as a lifeline quickly became another source of hardship.

Subsequent governmental policies continued to fall short of providing effective relief. In 1847, Britain began direct help through free food distribution via soup kitchens, feeding three million people by August. However, this initiative came too late for many who had succumbed to hunger or disease. Worse, when the fall harvest was good, the programme abruptly ended. This temporary and poorly executed measure highlighted the British government’s inability to meet the needs of the Irish population during the crisis.

However, the famine’s tragedy was not solely due to food shortages; the neglect of Irish needs extended further. An exploitative land tenure system, where absentee landlords had the power to demand high rents from poor tenant farmers, exacerbated the crisis. Landlords evicted tenants unable to pay rent, leaving them homeless. Further, the British government largely refrained from interfering in the economy. Adherence to a laissez-faire approach meant minimal intervention, avoiding any significant disruption of market conditions. The concern was that the provision of substantial relief would foster dependency on Britain and undermine the workings of the free market.

Emigration was another tragic consequence of the famine, with over a million people fleeing Ireland in search of survival. Many emigrants faced perilous journeys aboard ‘coffin ships’, where disease and malnutrition were rampant. The mass exodus had severe long-term effects, both on the depopulated areas of Ireland and on the Irish diaspora worldwide.

By 1847, Britain began to withdraw its economic responsibilities. With the introduction of the Poor Law Extension Act, the burden of the famine was shifted to the landowners and the poor themselves. This act required local landlords to fund relief efforts, but many were already bankrupt or unwilling to provide aid. This policy failed to alleviate the suffering and led to widespread evictions, as landlords sought to rid themselves of financially burdensome tenants.

Historian Peter Gray observes how “pure laissez-faire was never the classical prescription for Ireland,” underscoring the inadequacy of the approach. The limited effectiveness of government actions was largely a result of ideological rigidity, which placed undue faith in the ability of market forces to resolve the crisis. Once Ireland was perceived as a ‘viable’ entity, the conservative British leadership was positioned to withdraw support.

The Great Famine of 1845 was, without question, a tragedy shaped by deliberate and flawed human decisions. While some may argue that Britain initially responded with measures aimed at addressing Irish needs, these actions were neither sufficient nor sustained. The attempts to alleviate the suffering were too inconsistent and half-hearted to offer any real hope of recovery. What Ireland desperately needed was a Britain committed to rescuing it from the depths of starvation but instead received one that was more concerned with its own interests. The famine stands as a tragic example of a man-made catastrophe, driven by neglect and misplaced priorities.

Bibliography

Gray, Peter, Famine, Land, and Politics: British Government and Irish Society, 1843-50 (Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 1999)

Kinealy, Christine, A Death-Dealing Famine: The Great Hunger in Ireland (Chicago: Pluto Press, 1997)

Powderly, William G., ‘How Infection Shaped History: Lessons from the Irish Famine’, Trans Am Clin Climatol Assoc, 130 (2019), p.127-135

Smith, Dan, ‘The Irish Potato Famine’, Short History of…, audio podcast, Noiser, 16 January 2023 <https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p0g8msxw> [accessed 2 August 2024]

Williams, Leslie, Daniel O’Connell, the British Press, and the Irish Famine: Killing Remarks (London / New York: Routledge, 2016)